Skip to main content

Field reports

Tri-Color next to tracer gas in a pharma lab

One 8 ft bench hood, tested both ways at three face velocities. Tri-Color flagged the trouble spot before tracer gas was run there, and at 70 fpm it showed escape where the probe read 0.00 ppm.

Lab

Pharmaceutical R&D (name withheld)

Location

Northeast U.S.

Hood

8 ft bench, combination sash, VAV

Methods

Tri-Color; ASHRAE 110-2016 SF₆ tracer gas, Q200 analyzer

Setpoints

100 fpm as installed, then 50 and 70 fpm

Result

Tri-Color found the trouble spot first and showed escape the probe didn't register at 70 fpm

3

face velocities, both methods at each

First

Tri-Color flagged the horizontal openings before tracer gas was run there

0.00 ppm

tracer gas at 70 fpm, at the spot where Tri-Color showed escape

The ask

The number, and the picture

The lab's lead engineer needed as-installed ASHRAE 110 tracer gas results and wanted to see dynamic containment testing next to it. We ran Tri-Color beside tracer gas on an 8 ft bench hood with a combination sash on VAV controls.

How it worked

Same hood, same day

Tri-Color's laser curtain at the sash plane, the mannequin and probe on the same hood. Both ran at 100 fpm as installed. Then the controls contractor turned the hood down to 50 fpm and back up to 70 fpm, each setpoint confirmed at the opening, and we ran both again.

What Tri-Color showed

Where it leaks, and when

At 100 fpm the red laser dipped low at the horizontal panel openings; tracer gas then failed there on a 0.27 ppm peak against the spec's 0.10 ppm. At 50 fpm both failed. At 70 fpm Tri-Color showed escape at the left side while tracer gas at that spot read 0.00 ppm.

Side by side

Same spot, two different answers

ConditionTri-ColorSF₆ tracer gasTogether
100 fpm, vertical sashNo loss of containment0.00 ppm avg, 0.00 peak at left, center, right. PassAgree
100 fpm, horizontal panelsRed laser dipping low at the openings, a precursor to loss0.27 ppm peak at center. FailTri-Color flagged it first
50 fpm, left, vertical sashClear, sustained loss at the left side0.12 ppm avg, 0.75 peak. FailBoth fail
70 fpm, left, vertical sashPersistent loss at the left side0.00 ppm avg, 0.00 peak. PassTri-Color sees what the probe doesn’t
Tri-Color at 70 fpm showing haze crossing the laser curtain at the left side of the opening
Tri-Color at 70 fpm: escape at the left side
Tracer gas chart, left position at 70 fpm, flat at 0.00 ppm for the full 300 seconds
Tracer gas at the same spot: 0.00 ppm for 300 seconds

The 50 and 70 fpm runs were below the hood’s installed setpoint, outside its as-installed rating.

Test mannequin at the left position of the hood with the tracer gas ejector inside the sash

Two methods, two questions

Tracer gas tells you how much reached one point: a still mannequin’s breathing zone. Tri-Color shows whether anything crosses the sash plane, anywhere along the opening, in real time, with people working at the hood. When the loss was big enough to reach the probe, at 50 fpm, both agreed, so Tri-Color isn’t raising false alarms. It sees the same event earlier and across the whole opening.

Tracer gas gives you a number to hold against a spec. Tri-Color shows whether the hood holds, and where to look when it doesn’t.

That isn’t a fault in tracer gas. It’s a limit of one probe at one point.

From the test

Tri-Color lasers at the sash plane of the bench hood, vertical sash open, no smoke crossing
100 fpm, vertical sash: lasers steady
Tri-Color with the horizontal sliding panels open, red laser layer dipping low at the opening
100 fpm, horizontal panels: red laser dipping low
Tracer gas chart, center horizontal opening at 100 fpm, flat line with one 0.27 ppm spike near 195 seconds
Center horizontal opening: the 0.27 ppm peak at about 195 s
Red Tri-Color haze escaping at the left side of the hood opening at 50 fpm
50 fpm: clear, sustained loss at the left side

See it work.

Questions first? 623-562-0907